Most of the gap between two roofing quotes hides in a handful of lines. Some of those lines are set by state law.
Figures checked
Checklist3 min read
Published
Check six things: the roof area and rate per m², whether removal of the old roof is priced, the licence or
registration number, a written contract where the law requires one, the exclusions, and the deposit. Deposits are
capped at 10% in New South Wales, and in Queensland and Victoria the cap falls as the
contract gets bigger.
A quote does not have to look like this, but it does have to answer these six things. Each one is explained below.
Does the quote show the roof area and the rate?
A total with no area behind it cannot be compared with anything. Ask for the measured roof area and the rate per
square metre, then check the rate against published ranges: Roofing Calculator HQ lists
$120 to $170 per m² for Colorbond and $70 to $120 per m² for concrete tile, while Yellow Pages
puts the market average at $80 to $230 per m². Two quotes measured on different areas will differ by
thousands for reasons that have nothing to do with price. The
calculator turns an area and a material into a range in a few seconds.
Is removal of the old roof its own line?
This is where published guides disagree most. Roofing Calculator HQ puts strip-off at $8 to $14 per m²,
calling it a point to negotiate, while Yellow Pages puts removal and disposal at $20 to $50 per m². If
your quote bundles removal into the rate, you cannot tell which of those you are paying. Ask for it split out, with
disposal named.
Is the contractor licensed or registered for a job this size?
Where the paperwork rules startcontract valueShow the numbers
Item
Value
Source
QLD: licence and contract
$3,300
Queensland Building and Construction Commission, when you need a licence
NSW: written contract
$5,000
NSW Government, contracts for residential building work
VIC: registered domestic builder
$10,000
Building and Plumbing Commission (Victoria), what is domestic building work
NSW: Home Building Compensation
$20,000
NSW Government, contracts for residential building work
Official figures. Source: Queensland Building and Construction Commission, when you need a licence; NSW Government, contracts for residential building work; Building and Plumbing Commission (Victoria), what is domestic building work.
In Queensland, building work over $3,300 must be performed by an appropriately licensed person and
accompanied by a contract. In Victoria, a domestic builder must be registered for domestic building work costing
more than $10,000, so ask whether your job counts as domestic building work. Then check the number
itself with the state regulator rather than the business's own website.
Is there a written contract?
In New South Wales a written contract is required for residential building work over $5,000
including GST, and Home Building Compensation cover is required more than $20,000. Queensland requires a
contract on work over $3,300. A roofing job clears these thresholds easily, so a one-page emailed
price is not the finished paperwork.
Is the deposit inside the legal cap?
Maximum deposit by state and contract size% of the contract priceShow the numbers
Item
Value
Source
QLD, $3,300 or less
20%
Queensland Building and Construction Commission, deposits and progress payments
QLD, level 1 contract
10%
Queensland Building and Construction Commission, deposits and progress payments
QLD, level 2 contract
5%
Queensland Building and Construction Commission, deposits and progress payments
NSW, any residential job
10%
NSW Government, contracts for residential building work
VIC, under $20,000
10%
Consumer Affairs Victoria, deposits and payments for building work
VIC, $20,000 or more
5%
Consumer Affairs Victoria, deposits and payments for building work
Official figures. Source: Queensland Building and Construction Commission, deposits and progress payments; NSW Government, contracts for residential building work; Consumer Affairs Victoria, deposits and payments for building work.
A deposit above the cap is not a negotiating position, it is a breach of the rule the cap sits in. In Queensland,
paying more than the lawful deposit also reduces your cover under the Home Warranty Scheme.
What does the quote leave out?
Exclusions belong in writing. On a re-roof the usual ones are gutters, scaffolding and access, structural repairs
found once the old roof is off, insulation, and anything asbestos. Each has its own guide here:
gutters,
asbestos and
wind class fixings.
Five things worth a second look
A deposit above the state cap.
No licence or registration number anywhere on the document.
A lump sum with no roof area and no rate.
"Removal included" with no quantity and no disposal named.
A discount for paying cash and skipping the written contract.
Contract, licence and deposit rules on this page come from official regulator pages in three states, linked below.
Other states set their own thresholds, and we have not checked those yet.